Notoriously Morbid Mystic Monthly - April 2017 | Blog My Backlog

What is Notoriously Morbid Mystic Monthly?: Mystic Monthly is a new monthly subscription from Notoriously Morbid featuring the legendary Mystic Mattes liquid lipsticks. Each year has a theme (2017 is The Witches' Inn) and each month comes with one full-size limited edition Mystic Matte and one additional full-size lip product.

How Much is Mystic Monthly?: Mystic Monthly is $10 in the US (including shipping) and $16 for those international (also including shipping).

For past reviews of Notoriously Morbid, just click here!



For the April Mystic Monthly, the witch was Tituba, the first to be accused and confess to being a witch during the Salem Trials.



Info card.


Tituba is a dark purple with red and gold sparkles and a violet red base.


Star stencil from Polished Vino.


Macro of Tituba.


Tituba was a little patchy upon initial application. Some areas were the true deep purple whereas others really only showed the violet red base. I've worn this on other occasions and found that if you place the pigment down more specifically and then smooth out afterward. This is a gorgeous color and I love how the sparkles come out.


Overall, I really liked the lippie. It's a gorgeous purple and looks so pretty on! The Night Kiss Lip Balm is a mix of fresh coconut scented with notes of caked, which really just makes me hungry more than anything else. 

As always, let me know what you thought of this bag in the comments!


Kiersten Faythe
Kiersten Faythe

A lifestyle blog focusing on makeup, subscription boxes, and nail polish.